Friday, May 25, 2012

INEQUITY: Politics and Felony Population Distribution


During a March committee hearing about a bill that addressed Good Landlord Programs in the State, a comment was made by a member of the Ogden City administration about the need for the program.  It was declared that the program was specifically created to help mitigate the large felony population that the State dumps in Ogden via State run halfway houses.  The claim was made that over half of the State run halfway houses are in Ogden.

I was shocked by this claim.  When our Session ended, I came home and started to do some research to check the veracity of the comment.  What I found surprised me.

As it turns out, the State of Utah isn't doing Weber County any favors when it comes to equally distributing inmates in halfway houses.  Here are some charts to illustrate:


As you can see, Weber County comprises just 8.24% of the State's population.  Salt Lake County accounts for 36.7%.

So how is the halfway house inmate population distributed?  Queue the chart please...


As you can see, Weber County has 46% of all the halfway house beds in the state.  What an onerous distinction!

Amazingly, all of this burden is concentrated in one robust facility located on Watertower Way near I-15 and 24th Street.


Built in 1996, this facility has many resources under one roof to serve a host of inmate rehabilitation needs.  On the surface, the State and the taxpayer seem to be getting some economies of scale with this facility. Yet, lurking in the shadows are some significant and unintended consequences from creating such a large facility.

Among those are a decrease in inmate rehabilitation.  Indeed, success rates at the Weber County NUCCC facility are just 48%. I toured the facility with staff and interviewed them on their perceptions of the system. They agreed that smaller facilities are more successful in rehabilitation than larger ones because smaller facilities create a tighter family atmosphere where inmates become invested in each other's success.  Large facilities create anonymity and a warehouse atmosphere.  Thus, success is impeded.  That lack of success has a dollar tag attached to it in the form of prolonged incarcerations, property loss and damage from reoffending, and increased law enforcement costs to capture and prosecute reoffenders.

Another drawback is that while the State as a whole may obtain efficiencies in scale for the facility, the community in which it is placed must deal with the population that leaves the facility.  It is commonly asserted that offenders return to their hometowns after leaving a halfway house facility.  Data from a 2003 study shows that this is not true.    Here are the results of that study:


 As you can see, almost 20% of inmates that arrive from other areas STAY in Ogden after their release.  Over time, this net gain in felony population affects the quality of life in the surrounding community.  Hence, Ogden's pioneering of the Good Landlord Program.

So what is to be done?  In talking about the issue with my legislative colleauges, there appear to be  several daunting challenges to changing the status quo.

First, the NIMBY (not in my back yard) sentiment is very strong.  Obviously, any reduction in the number of beds in Ogden would mean an increase in beds somewhere else.  It's like trying to find a friendly harbor for spent nuclear waste.  Most of my colleagues who I spoke to about this issue vowed to vote against any change because they didn't want to tell their constituents they supported bringing felons to their neighborhood.

Second, the infrastructure costs are very expensive.  In a time when our capital maintenance and expenditures are under strain, spending new money on acquiring and building new facilities is politically difficult to justify in light of other demands for taxpayer money (i.e. education).

I find my colleagues' sentiments discouraging.  It would be ideal for communities to take care of their own inmates locally.  The small scale would promote success and the budget would be of small impact in the long run.  Also, since the NUCCC facility in Weber County is so new, it will likely be a decade or more before it obsolesces and new funds can be justified to create a new facility.  Whenever that occurs though, that will be the time to strike on this issue.

In the meantime, let's hope that there is a paradigm shift in correction circles of how our inmates should be distributed across the State.  If we are seriously interested in successful rehabilitation of our inmate population, this needs to happen.

Friday, May 18, 2012

Show Me The Money: Utah Government Spending 2012


The State of Utah has a giant budget of over $12 Billion.  The Legislature is tasked with appropriating these funds to various departments and programs to keep government operating.

Of course, there is always the political component of determining which programs should be funded and which ones should not.  For example, during interim session in 2011, a program director came to us asking to extend their funding another 10 years when they weren't even using half of the budget they had been allocated.  Our committee decided not only to prevent an extension but also moved to stop funding the program altogether.

During the General Session there are many Appropriation Subcommittees which specialize in various departments of government and the funding for such.  I happen to sit on the Economic Development Appropriations Subcommittee.

For those of you interested in where your tax dollars were spent this last year, here is the report:

    Utah State Fiscal Year 2013 Appropriations Report

Monday, May 7, 2012

VIDEO: Political Neutrality of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints Explained



Being a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints while also participating in politics has been an awkward dual role to acclimate too.  Much of the awkwardness has to do with respecting the political neutrality of the Church while at the same time participating in church activities and fellowship.

I can recall many times when members of my congregation would come up to me in a church hallway and say, "Hey, what do you think about [X] issue?".  I think people are naturally curious and excited to discuss issues, regardless of the venue, especially when someone they know is involved in the process.

Nevertheless, when spending most of my days at the State Capitol during the General Session and then returning home for weekend worship, I strive to be extra careful in filtering my comments about daily life in a way that avoids discussing political issues.  I also ask that people call me "Brother" Peterson rather than "Representative" when at church. 

As a reminder for faithful LDS folks and perhaps some new information for those who are not of the faith, here is a video animation that articulates the role of the church and its members in the realm of politics:


  

As we head toward election season, may our discourse we civil and held in the appropriate venues.

Monday, April 30, 2012

Veto Override Vote 2012

Many of you are aware that the Governor vetoed several bills that the legislature passed this last session.  Of the most controversial, HB363 or the Abstinence Only Sex Ed Bill was spiked. 

It is the prerogative of the Legislature to override a Governor's veto if it fills strongly enough on the issue. This year, leadership asked every member of the body to cast their vote on whether to initiate a Veto Override session.  Here is the outcome:

Veto Override Vote 2012

Friday, April 27, 2012

VIDEO: Left Hand Turn Redux

In 2011 I sponsored legislation to enhance the penalty for folks who killed someone when making a left hand turn.  Our initial proposal was to increase the fine from $90 to $500 and suspend a drivers license for 30 days.  Our proposal failed at committee.

With the recent sentencing of the driver involved in Ken Cox's death, Channel 4 picked up on the story.  They came to my Ogden office today to interview Kody Cox, ABATE, and myself.   Here is their report:




A special thanks to Kody and ABATE for bringing this issue to the media's attention. More driver awareness will help improve safety. I will be drafting legislation to see if we can discuss this issue again at the Capitol during the next legislative session.

The Case for Funding WSU's New Science Building


I had an opportunity to visit with David Matty, the Dean of the College of Science at WSU,  and tour the science facility at the University.  What I found was quite shocking.



Built in 1969, the edifice embodies all the trimmings of the structures built during that era.   I am sure at the time, the College of Science looked at its facility as boldly going where facilities had not gone before. 


It appears now, however, that this facility has been there and done that.  It's design lacks what most of us would consider desirable.  It has long windowless corridors with dreary cinder block labs and classrooms.


Here is an example of a working lab which was converted from an old cargo loading bay.  Check out the cool 5 1/4" floppy drives on those computers servicing the gas spectrochromotograph.  We have to give our college students and faculty credit for being resourceful enough to continue using this equipment, let alone improvising with the inadequate space they have.



Here is a classroom which is representative of most classrooms.  No, it's not in the basement; but you can't tell either way.


And while you are there make sure the ceiling doesn't drip something on you.  The dripping ruins tabletops.


 Space is so scarce that this chemical storage room doubles as an office storage closet.


What I found remarkable for "newer" 1960's construction (keep in mind that I work with 110 year old buildings for a living), the entire north section of the building sags.  The settling has telegraphed up several floors of the building and caused floor tiles to crack due to the stress.  This particular crack is about 8 feet long. 

 
Can I give you a hand?


The exterior of the building is laden with signs of deterioration.  The window panels are woefully inadequate for temperature control in the building as well.


The geography of the building couldn't be in a worse spot.  The Wasatch Fault scarp is located on the east end of the Science Building parking lot.    

Given that science and technology drive our economy, it doesn't speak well of WSU or the State of Utah to tolerate such poor conditions in this area.  How are we expected to recruit students to these important fields when providing such squalid facilities?

So, what is the solution to this issue?  The answer is the construction of a new facility to meet the needs of today's science students.  It is projected that a new structure will cost about $63 Million for 200,000 SQFT of space.  That is about $315/SQFT.  The average cost of construction across the U.S. for science buildings is about $400/SQFT.  Perhaps a new building should be designed to better withstand the test of time, be more adaptable to future needs, and constructed in such a manner to last for several generations. 

Here is a summary of the current proposal:
New Weber Science Building

It's time to take a fresh look at this project and at the very least provide the funds for planning and designing a new structure this next legislative season.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

THE BIG CHANGE: Population Metamorphosis and Policy Making

At the 2012 WFRC Consortium, we were presented with many interesting fact about Utah's demographic future.  Here is the slide show with charts and graphs that were were shown:

Consortium WFRC 2012 Data Slides

Quite fascinating statistics.  The presenters also took a live poll using a handheld voting device we were all given.  Here are the results of their questions and the answers:
Consortium Polling Results
The question results that made me laugh had to do with where people were from in the audience.  The overwhelming majority of us answered "Government".  Ha!  So, with that being said, I have to suggest that the market related answers given are biased and another poll should be given to developers and consumers alike.  After all, they tend to decide what kind of housing they will build and pay for with their own money.

The questions that remain to be answered are how the free marketplace and urban development will dovetail together to meet the needs of Utah's surging and changing population.